In Seeing Like A State, James C. Scott contrasts formalized systems of knowledge with what he calls mētis. Mētis is “a wide array of practical skills and acquired intelligence in responding to a constantly changing natural and human environment”. Mētis is usually associated with traditional forms of knowledge and formalized systems of knowledge with modernity. Scott resists this comparison because many “traditional” forms of knowledge only look ancient and can quickly adapt in response to new conditions. I agree and wanted to find an example where the reverse is true: where formal knowledge is traditional and mētis is new. I believe that I have found such an example in computer science.
Tag: Legibilism
Legibilism in Mormonism
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is a large, centralized institution. Since large, centralized institutions tend to be biased towards legibility, it is worth asking if this exists in Mormonism. I try to avoid value judgements here and allow you to decide if less legible institutions are better or worse for the Church.
Mētis and Science
Scott describes mētis and science as two distinct but complemented forms of knowledge with different methods and goals. If he were more familiar with practicing scientists, he would have thought that they are less distinct.
Book Review of AGAINST THE GRAIN by James C. Scott (2017)
Grains – wheat, barley, millet, rice, and corn – are the dominant food in all of the earliest states because they are the easiest to collect taxes on, not because they are the best for the people who farmed them.
Book Review of THE ART OF NOT BEING GOVERNED: AN ANARCHIST HISTORY OF UPLAND SOUTHEAST ASIA by James C. Scott (2009)
Scott’s expertise is the history of the people living in the hills of Southeast Asia. This people have been in contact with the largest state-building project in history (China) for thousands of years. They have arranged their societies to be anti-legible: to make it as hard as possible for the state or any large institution to establish itself.
Book Review of SEEING LIKE A STATE by James C. Scott (1998)
Seeing Like A State is the best political book I have ever read. I have long had tendencies along these lines, but could never put them into words. Scott expresses himself beautifully and cites numerous examples.